News

GameStop CEO Digital Games Criticism Puts GTA 6 Ownership on Trial

GameStop CEO Says Digital-Only Games Have 'Hurt Consumers' as GTA 6 Skips Discs
Big Brain
Big Brain
Published
11/19/2026
Read Time
5 min

Ryan Cohen says all-digital releases hurt consumers and GameStop, but GTA 6's code-in-a-box launch is only the latest pressure point in a wider fight over ownership, resale, and access.

GameStop CEO Says Digital-Only Games Have 'Hurt Consumers' as GTA 6 Skips Discs

Image: bitbase.com

Cohen’s line in the sand arrives with a code in a box

GameStop CEO Ryan Cohen told Bloomberg that the industry’s shift away from discs has damaged both buyers and his own retail chain, landing the argument at the exact moment Grand Theft Auto VI is being sold without a playable disc in the box. “When you buy a game, you should be able to sell it, trade it or lend it to a friend,” Cohen said in the Bloomberg interview, as quoted by multiple outlets. “Unquestionably, the decision to move to all digital has hurt consumers, and it’s also hurt GameStop.”

The immediate flashpoint is GTA 6, which Bloomberg, Quartz, Decrypt, Eurogamer, Kotaku, and IGN all describe as a download-only release at launch. Retailers are still selling boxed copies, but those boxes contain download codes rather than discs. Quartz reported that Take-Two Interactive’s standard edition is priced at $80, while BigGo Finance reported a $99.99 ultimate edition alongside the $80 standard edition. Cohen’s own summary of GameStop’s position was blunt when Bloomberg asked about presales: “It’s a code in a box. I mean, we’re selling a lot of it.”

That line captures the strategic contradiction. GameStop can still participate in the launch-day transaction, but a code-in-a-box sale does not create the used-copy loop that made physical retail valuable for decades. The store gets the first sale. It does not get the later trade-in, the resale, or the foot traffic that follows from a customer turning one game into credit for the next.

The ownership claim and the retail incentive are inseparable

Cohen’s consumer argument is simple: a disc gives the buyer options a download code usually does not. A disc can be lent, resold, traded, or shelved. A redeemed code is tied to an account and cannot move through the same secondhand market. That is why the phrase “digital games hurt consumers” is doing two jobs at once in this dispute. It describes a perceived loss of buyer control, and it describes a direct hit to GameStop physical games as a business model.

Bloomberg reported, via Quartz and Decrypt, that pre-owned and refurbished products made up 22% of GameStop’s sales in the quarter ending August 1, amounting to about $171 million, down 32% from the prior year. Those numbers explain why the issue is existential for a retailer even if digital storefronts are convenient for many players. Used inventory is not only a cheaper alternative for customers. It is also a rival price layer that publishers do not control.

Cohen made that competitive point explicitly. He told Bloomberg he had spoken with “the obvious” publishers and argued that limiting trade-ins helps them because used copies compete with new sales. “Of course they don’t like [trade-ins] because removing a used copy eliminates an alternative to buying new,” Cohen said. “They’re taking away competition.”

From a strategy perspective, the code-in-a-box format is the awkward middle phase of the transition. It preserves retail shelf space and giftability while stripping out the resale economy that made the box economically distinct. For publishers, that is cleaner revenue capture. For retailers, it is a lower-value transaction. For players, the tradeoff depends on whether convenience outweighs the loss of transferability.

GTA 6 is the scale test, not the whole story

GTA 6 matters here because its scale can normalize a format faster than a dozen smaller launches. Eurogamer described it as expected to be the biggest video game launch of all time. The available estimates vary by source and timing: IGN cited analysts estimating preorders neared 20 million before release, Eurogamer cited Sensor Tower figures of well over 19.05 million units at the time of writing, and BigGo Finance reported more than 17 million copies sold for about $1.65 billion by Thursday morning. Those figures are not identical, but they point in the same direction: the absence of a disc has not been reported as a launch-stopping obstacle.

That is the uncomfortable part for physical-media advocates. If a game of this size can launch with boxes that only contain codes and still generate record-level demand, publishers will read the result as evidence that the market has absorbed the change. Eurogamer also reported expectations that GTA 6 could cross $2 billion in its opening weekend, based on analyst estimates. Whether that exact threshold is reached is separate from the larger signal publishers will be watching: how many players object loudly, and how many still buy.

Cohen did not name GTA 6 in the Bloomberg interview, according to IGN and other outlets, but his timing and public comments made the connection clear. Two days earlier, he posted on X: “GTA. On a disc. In a case. On your shelf. Like if you still want a physical copy.” Kotaku and Quartz both cited that post.

There are also practical frictions that weaken the argument that codes are simply a more flexible version of physical distribution. Eurogamer reported that GTA 6 codes are region-locked, at least on PS5, which means the format does not automatically solve access problems across markets. A box with a code can look like a physical product at retail, but it behaves like a digital entitlement once redeemed.

The industry roadmap is already tilted toward digital

The ownership fight would look different if GTA 6 were an isolated experiment. The source material points the other way. Decrypt reported that Sony announced in July that it will stop producing physical discs for new PlayStation games in January 2028. Eurogamer also reported that Sony plans to move away from physical discs for new PlayStation releases starting in January 2028, despite pushback from consumers and some developers and publishers.

Kotaku added another data point from Capcom, which has said that 90% of its unit sales are digital. That figure does not settle the ownership debate, and Kotaku noted that unit share is not the same thing as revenue mix, but it does show the direction of player behavior at major publishers. Digital is no longer a side channel. For many companies, it is the dominant channel.

Take-Two leadership has also defended the logic of skipping discs. IGN reported that Take-Two boss Strauss Zelnick previously said discs “don’t really make sense for the consumer” for big games because players need to be connected today. According to IGN, Zelnick later refused to rule out a GTA 6 disc version “at some point,” which leaves the door open without creating a concrete promise. As of the sourced reporting, there is no announced disc version for GTA 6.

GameStop’s own messaging has been less stable than Cohen’s latest comments suggest. IGN reported that Cohen said in a July Bloomberg podcast that physical game sales were “totally, totally irrelevant” to GameStop’s future, arguing that the company had been pivoting toward higher-margin collectibles and trading cards. His November comments do not erase that earlier position. They expose the tension between a retailer trying to diversify away from software and a business that still benefits when the biggest games produce tradeable objects.

The ownership debate has moved into politics

The fight over physical media is now tied to a broader legal argument about whether buying a game should guarantee continuing access. Quartz and Decrypt reported that Cohen has met with Rep. Ritchie Torres, a New York Democrat backing the Power to the Players Act. Bloomberg, as cited by Quartz, described the bill as requiring game makers to guarantee buyers continued access to what they have purchased.

Torres framed the issue in October as a consumer-rights problem. “When you pay for a game, you should own it,” he said, according to Bloomberg via Quartz and Decrypt. “A game that can be taken away the moment a company pulls the plug is not a purchase. It is a rental disguised as a sale.”

That argument overlaps with physical-media advocacy, but it is not identical. A disc can preserve resale rights and collector value, yet many modern games still depend on servers, patches, account systems, or platform authentication. Conversely, a digital law focused on ongoing access would not automatically restore the right to resell a downloaded title. The shared concern is control: who decides whether a buyer can keep using, transferring, or accessing a game after the first sale?

Europe has a parallel pressure campaign. Decrypt and Quartz reported that the Stop Killing Games movement gathered 1.3 million signatures for a European Citizens’ Initiative seeking rules that would require publishers to keep titles playable. The source material does not establish that either the U.S. bill or the European effort will become law. It does show that the debate has outgrown nostalgia for shelves and manuals. It is now a policy argument about the boundary between a purchase and a revocable license.

A practical read for players deciding what to buy

For players looking at GTA 6 specifically, the sourced reporting supports a narrow conclusion: if you want the game at launch through retail, the “physical” version is a box with a download code, not a disc. If you want a disc, IGN has reported that Zelnick has not ruled out one arriving someday, but no source here confirms a planned disc edition, a date, an upgrade path, or a trade-in route.

That makes the buying decision less about packaging and more about future flexibility. A code bought at GameStop may satisfy someone who wants a case on the shelf or a giftable retail product before redemption. It will not satisfy someone whose priority is lending the game to a friend, reselling it later, or building a durable disc library. For budget-conscious players, the missing resale layer matters because used copies historically created lower-price entry points after launch. The sources do not provide timing for discounts, so waiting for a sale is a general consumer choice rather than a confirmed GTA 6 plan.

For retailers, the strategic problem is sharper. A blockbuster code sale can produce revenue today while weakening tomorrow’s inventory cycle. That is why Cohen can say GameStop is selling a lot of GTA 6 while also arguing that digital games hurt consumers and GameStop. Both statements can be true inside the same quarter.

The larger market will be shaped by three forces now moving in the same direction: publishers seeking cleaner full-price sales, platform holders reducing disc infrastructure, and consumers increasingly buying through digital storefronts. Physical advocates still have public campaigns, political allies, and a clear ownership argument. Their problem is leverage. GTA 6’s discless release is the latest test of whether consumer resistance can change publisher strategy before discs become a premium exception rather than the default.

Share: